谓词推入导致的数据不一致案例

现象

下面的语句, 能查到deviceid 为dev005m0的记录, 但是加上deviceid = ‘dev005m0’这个条件后, 查询语句查不出结果了。
语句如下:

select * from 
(    select deviceid deviceid, port, cvlan, status, funcswitch, 
            decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, pvlan) svlan,
            decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, 
            lead(pvlan)over(partition by deviceid, port, cvlan, status order by pvlan asc)) evlan
     from   vlanstatus_pre2bak
)
where  funcswitch <> 2 and evlan is null  -- and  deviceid = 'dev005m0';

当注释掉deviceid = ‘dev005m0’, 查询结果如下:

当增加deviceid = ‘dev005m0’,查询结果没有记录:

deviceid的数据类型为char(8), vlanstatus_pre2bak的deviceid数据也没有空格等特殊字符, 非常诡异。下面来具体分析。

分析如下

1. 查询语句, 查询没有记录

select * from 
(    select deviceid deviceid, port, cvlan, status, funcswitch, 
            decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, pvlan) svlan,
            decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, 
            lead(pvlan)over(partition by deviceid, port, cvlan, status order by pvlan asc)) evlan
     from   vlanstatus_pre2bak
)
where  funcswitch <> 2 and evlan is null  and  deviceid = 'dev005m0' ;

或者:

with tmptab as
(    
    select  deviceid deviceid, port, cvlan, status, funcswitch, 
            decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, pvlan) svlan,
            decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, 
            lead(pvlan)over(partition by deviceid, port, cvlan, status order by pvlan asc)) evlan
     from   vlanstatus_pre2bak
)
select * from tmptab 
where  funcswitch <> 2 and evlan is null  and  deviceid = 'dev005m0' ;

查看执行计划:

sql> set lines 200
sql> set pages 200
sql> explain plan for
  2  select * from 
  3  (    select deviceid deviceid, port, cvlan, status, funcswitch, 
  4              decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, pvlan) svlan,
  5              decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, 
  6              lead(pvlan)over(partition by deviceid, port, cvlan, status order by pvlan asc)) evlan
  7       from   vlanstatus_pre2bak
  8  )
  9  where  funcswitch <> 2 and evlan is null  and  deviceid = 'dev005m0' ;

已解释。

sql> select * from table(dbms_xplan.display);

plan_table_output
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
plan hash value: 2175325539

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| id  | operation           | name               | rows  | bytes | cost (%cpu)| time     |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|   0 | select statement    |                    |    70 | 49350 |   692   (1)| 00:00:09 |
|*  1 |  view               |                    |    70 | 49350 |   692   (1)| 00:00:09 |
|   2 |   window sort       |                    |    70 |  3430 |   692   (1)| 00:00:09 |
|*  3 |    table access full| vlanstatus_pre2bak |    70 |  3430 |   691   (1)| 00:00:09 |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

predicate information (identified by operation id):
---------------------------------------------------

   1 - filter("funcswitch"<>2 and "evlan" is null)
   3 - filter("deviceid"='dev005m0')

已选择16行。

sql> 

查看id为3的谓词过滤(3 – filter(“deviceid”=’dev005m0′)), 说明先在表vlanstatus_pre2bak执行了deviceid = ‘dev005m0’操作。id为1的谓词过滤只有两个(1 – filter(“funcswitch”<>2 and “evlan” is null)),说明这个查询语句先在子查询里面过滤了deviceid = ‘dev005m0’的记录,然后在整个查询视图执行过滤条件funcswitch<>2 and evlan is null。这个现象就是谓词推入。

2. 使用materialize的hint避免谓词推入

with tmptab as
(    
    select  /*+materialize*/ deviceid deviceid, port, cvlan, status, funcswitch, 
            decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, pvlan) svlan,
            decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, 
            lead(pvlan)over(partition by deviceid, port, cvlan, status order by pvlan asc)) evlan
     from   vlanstatus_pre2bak
)
select * from tmptab 
where  funcswitch <> 2 and evlan is null  and  deviceid = 'dev005m0' ;

sql> set lines 200
sql> set pages 200
sql> explain plan for 
  2  with tmptab as
  3  (    
  4      select  /*+materialize*/ deviceid deviceid, port, cvlan, status, funcswitch, 
  5              decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, pvlan) svlan,
  6              decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, 
  7              lead(pvlan)over(partition by deviceid, port, cvlan, status order by pvlan asc)) evlan
  8       from   vlanstatus_pre2bak
  9  )
 10  select * from tmptab 
 11  where  funcswitch <> 2 and evlan is null  and  deviceid = 'dev005m0' ;

已解释。

sql> select * from table(dbms_xplan.display);

plan_table_output
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
plan hash value: 1444871666

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| id  | operation                  | name                        | rows  | bytes |tempspc| cost (%cpu)| time     |
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|   0 | select statement           |                             |   313k|   210m|       |  5062   (1)| 00:01:01 |
|   1 |  temp table transformation |                             |       |       |       |            |          |
|   2 |   load as select           | sys_temp_0fd9d66ce_df9dbbfb |       |       |       |            |          |
|   3 |    window sort             |                             |   313k|    14m|    20m|  4492   (1)| 00:00:54 |
|   4 |     table access full      | vlanstatus_pre2bak          |   313k|    14m|       |   690   (1)| 00:00:09 |
|*  5 |   view                     |                             |   313k|   210m|       |   570   (1)| 00:00:07 |
|   6 |    table access full       | sys_temp_0fd9d66ce_df9dbbfb |   313k|    14m|       |   570   (1)| 00:0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

predicate information (identified by operation id):
---------------------------------------------------

   5 - filter("funcswitch"<>2 and "evlan" is null and "deviceid"='dev005m0')

已选择18行。

sql> 

查看id为5的谓词过滤条件, 三个条件都是发生在视图view上面。

3. 使用trim或者拼接一个空的字符

select * from 
(    select trim(deviceid) deviceid, port, cvlan, status, funcswitch, 
            decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, pvlan) svlan,
            decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, 
            lead(pvlan)over(partition by deviceid, port, cvlan, status order by pvlan asc)) evlan
     from   vlanstatus_pre2bak
)
where  funcswitch <> 2 and evlan is null and  deviceid = 'dev005m0' ;

查看执行计划:

sql> set lines 200
sql> set lines 300
sql> set pages 200
sql> explain plan for 
  2  select * from 
  3  (    select trim(deviceid) deviceid, port, cvlan, status, funcswitch, 
  4              decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, pvlan) svlan,
  5              decode(funcswitch, 3, pvlan, 1, 
  6              lead(pvlan)over(partition by deviceid, port, cvlan, status order by pvlan asc)) evlan
  7       from   vlanstatus_pre2bak
  8  ) 
  9  where  funcswitch <> 2 and evlan is null and  deviceid = 'dev005m0';

已解释。

sql> select * from table(dbms_xplan.display);

plan_table_output
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
plan hash value: 2175325539

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| id  | operation           | name               | rows  | bytes |tempspc| cost (%cpu)| time     |
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|   0 | select statement    |                    |   313k|   209m|       |  4492   (1)| 00:00:54 |
|*  1 |  view               |                    |   313k|   209m|       |  4492   (1)| 00:00:54 |
|   2 |   window sort       |                    |   313k|    14m|    20m|  4492   (1)| 00:00:54 |
|   3 |    table access full| vlanstatus_pre2bak |   313k|    14m|       |   690   (1)| 00:00:09 |
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

predicate information (identified by operation id):
---------------------------------------------------

   1 - filter("funcswitch"<>2 and "evlan" is null and "deviceid"='dev005m0')

已选择15行。

sql> 

查看谓词过滤, 三个过滤条件都发生在id为1的view上面。
小海蟹出品

(0)
上一篇 2022年3月22日
下一篇 2022年3月22日

相关推荐